Investment Property Ownership – Your Vesting Options

Investing in real estate involves not only choosing the right property but also deciding how to vest it – a pivotal decision with far-reaching consequences. In this guide, we will delve into the nuances of individual ownership, business entities, and trusts, examining each option’s pros, cons, costs, and risks. As a new investor, understanding the legal protections and impact on lending can shape a decision tailored to your investment goals.

Individual Ownership: The Solo Venture

Individual ownership, the simplest form of vesting, provides full control and minimal upfront costs. Simple is not always best, however, and in individual vesting personal liability is a significant concern, as your personal assets are vulnerable in legal matters.

While simple in nature, it’s essential to note that this option is the weakest in terms of legal protections, leaving the owner exposed to personal liability from potential issues with tenants or renters. The lack of a protective entity structure means personal assets are vulnerable in legal matters. Many new landlords may be turning a past primary residence or second home into a rental without considering the vulnerability, which can return to bite them.  This consideration should be part of any plan for a property and to fully consider the potential risks and limitations associated with individual ownership.

Not withstanding the innate liability risks, this type of vesting is the easiest to get funding for.  Conventional programs are limited to this and some trusts which I will cover later, but this is also a strength for financing the property.  This gives investors the greatest number of lenders, programs and terms.  Some lenders start with individual vesting to secure financing and change it later.  While generally accepted by investors as a strategy, lenders do not feel the same way about changes.  In fact, many mortgage documents forbid doing this and, by doing so, you can be in breach of what you agreed to at closing.  While lenders do not necessarily do audits of this, they can and if they identify you have moved into a non-authorized vesting structure, they can force you to re-vest as an individual or they can even call the loan.  While that is rare, you will need to identify vesting when you refinance into another conventional loan and this can show your hand and force you to move back into individual vesting.

Business Entity: The Power of Structure

Opting for a business entity adds a protective layer, shielding personal assets from business-related liabilities.  Investors choosing this option need to understand that their will be both initial and regular administrative costs associated with the business entity.

This vesting type does offer much more personal legal protection by providing a layer of ownership between you and a tenant.  This comes with much more complexity than the individual vesting. Owners choosing to form a business entity, must establish clear operating agreements and maintain corporate records safeguards against potential legal issues.  Vesting in a business also comes with the need for separate tax returns for the entity which adds even more need for time and resources for their preparation as well as the cost to file.

As I covered earlier, this is not an option for conventional financing, so it will decrease the variety of lenders who can finance your property.  Only non-conventional lenders will consider properties vested in the name of a business, which limits options and, therefore, the terms that the investor will have to choose from.  These terms will likely be less favorable than the conventional alternatives as lenders price based on the risk that they assume by extending funds and these types of loans bring more risk and less flexibility to securitize and sell the loans later.

Trust Vesting: The Strategic Approach

Trust vesting offers asset protection and streamlined property transfer, adding strategic benefits.  This is the least common vesting that I see, but it does offer some advantages to the other aforementioned options.

The legal protection comes from the separation between the trustee and beneficiaries, shielding assets from personal issues.  In this way, it is more like business entity vesting.  With the protections comes similar costs.  Creating a trust involves legal documentation, reinforcing the importance of proper legal guidance.  It also comes with some of the regular maintenance costs and requirements that investors should consider.

Lending options are somewhat in the middle ground as well.  There will no doubt be more lenders willing to lend in this vesting type, but that does not mean all lenders.  The challenge can be in the type of trust and lenders who allow this vesting in trusts will clearly define which ones they allow.  This can make finding a lender who will accept your trust a drain on resources as the investor may need to call around.  The process will also likely take longer as the lender and sometimes the title company will need to fully review the trust documents, which typically is done through a separate department.

Know Your Vesting Options

Navigating the maze of property vesting requires a nuanced understanding of individual ownership, business entities, and trusts. Legal protection considerations, such as forming an LLC for individual ownership or maintaining meticulous records for business entities, enhance your safeguards. When it comes to lending, each vesting type has its nuances, with careful consideration needed when changing post-loan acquisition. As a new investor, balancing legal protection and lending considerations is key to making an informed decision that sets the stage for a successful real estate investment journey.

Have an immediate need for investment real estate financing or just looking to be ready  when you find that perfect property?